Chuck roast, brisket method, dinner tonight

Poor man's brisket

Weekend · 5–7 hr · Oak or hickory

Time
5–7 hr
Pit
275°
Wood
Oak or hickory
Serves
6–8

Same salt-and-pepper, same wrap, same probe-tender finish — half the time and half the bill. Slice it like brisket or shred it for sandwiches. Collagen is the whole game.

Chuck roast temps

Cook-along

Watch it cooked

The method on this page is ours. The video is the pitmaster walking the same cook.

Smoked Chuck Roast, Poor Man's Brisket

Chiles and Smoke

Watch on YouTube

Ingredients

Roast

  • 1 chuck roast, 3–5 lb
  • Equal parts kosher salt and coarse black pepper
  • 1 tsp garlic powder (optional)
  • Yellow mustard or oil as a binder

Wrap

  • Pink butcher paper
  • 2 tbsp beef tallow or butter
  • Splash of beef broth

Method

  1. 1

    Trim only the hard surface fat. Binder, then a heavy salt-and-pepper crust on all sides. Rest 30 minutes.

  2. 2

    Pit 275°F, oak or hickory. Fat-side down.

  3. 3

    When the bark is set and internal is 160–170°F, wrap with tallow and a splash of broth.

  4. 4

    Continue to probe tender, typically 200–205°F. Rest 30–45 minutes.

  5. 5

    Slice against the grain for plates. For sandwiches, shred and mix the wrap juices back in.

Sliceable chuck can stop around 195°F. Pulled chuck wants 205°F.

This is also how you make poor-man's burnt ends — cube after the rest, sauce, 30 minutes more.

More cooks